alt
2012-06-12 17:31

Professor rekindles feud with Kim Yu-na


Hwang Sang-min
By Jung Min-ho

Professor Hwang Sang-min went back on the offensive against Olympic figure skating champion Kim Yu-na saying, “Kim is putting on another show by saying that she will drop the charges, if I make a public apology.”

Hwang used the same word that got him into trouble with Kim in the first place when he referred to her teaching practice as nothing but “a show” and that it lacked sincerity.

The Yonsei psychology professor said on a Channel A television program on Monday that he sent Kim a signed copy of his book as a token of apology but she refused to accept it, questioning his sincerity. For that, the 50-year-old scholar criticized Kim for “looking down upon others.”


Kim Yu-na
“Kim is a typical case of having achieved success at an early age, so, there is high chance for her to become unhappy as she gets older,” Hwang said. “She is a celebrity at this point, but she is likely to make her exit to become a coach or professor and there is no guarantee that she would not plagiarize in the process of getting her master’s and doctorate degrees like Moon Dae-sung did.”

During the program, Hwang commented on the recent controversy, saying his calling Kim’s teaching practice a show on a CBS radio show drew attention and his true intention was overly misinterpreted.

“Colleges only provide celebrities and sports stars with opportunities to study but the schools don’t actually educate them,” Hwang said.

The Ivy League-educated professor’s remarks soon rekindled the debate concerning the legitimacy of the privileges celebrities enjoy in terms of getting degrees while often having to put in far less effort compared to other students, adding fuel to the fire.

While many slammed Hwang for “making insulting comments on Korea’s figure skating heroine who enhanced the nation’s prestige,” others defended his position saying, “He made some legitimate points concerning the issue, although the tone was somewhat aggressive.”

Shortly after the professor questioned the intent behind Kim’s teaching practice, the 21-year-old filed a defamation law suit against him on May 30, a move the Seoul Southern District Prosecutors’ Office has confirmed.

Kim’s agency, All That Sports, said it would drop the charges at any time if Hwang makes a sincere public apology. Hwang appeared on YTN radio show claiming he had apologized to Kim. He has also said he will drop out of a radio program he regularly participates in as a further token of apology.

In case the two sides fail to reach a reconciliation, the feud concerning the favoritism for athletes in colleges is expected to grow, as the lawsuit proceeds.




관련 한글 기사


황상민 교수, 논쟁에 다시 불을 지피다.

“사과하면, 고소를 취하 하겠다는 것도 쇼하는 것.

황상민 교수는 지난 11일 채널 A ‘박종진의 시사토크 쾌도난마’에 출연해, 자신이 김연아 선수의 교생실습을 가리켜 ‘쇼’라고 발언한 것과 더불어 김연아 측에서 자신을 명예훼손 죄로 고소한 것에 대해 심정을 토로했다.

황교수는 사과하는 뜻에서 자신의 직접 사인한 책을 김연아 측에 선물했지만 진정성을 보이길 요구했다며, 그 의중은 “내게 창피를 주고 인격살인을 하겠다는 것”이라고 주장했다.

또한 황교수는, 처음 논란이 되었던 자신의 발언 중, 오직 ‘쇼’ 라고 한 부분만 부각이 되었다면서 자신이 진정 하고 싶었던 말은 전달되지 않았다고 말했다. 당시 문제의 핵심이었던 스포츠 스타와 연예인들의 대학 내 특혜에 대해서는, “체육스타나 연예인에게 대학 측에서 다양한 대학교육 기회를 제공하지만 제대로 교육하는 것은 아니다”며 “대학 졸업장이 하나의 간판이고 자신을 위한 방패로 활용” 하는 현재 한국 사회의 풍토에 대해서도 다시 한번 꼬집었다.

이번 황교수의 발언은 다시 한번 ‘김연아 논쟁’에 불을 지피며, 온라인을 뜨겁게 달구었다. 몇몇 사람들이 “황교수의 발언이 국가적인 위상을 높이는데 기여한 김연아에게 너무 가혹하고 편파적” 이라고 주장한 반면, 또 다른 측에서는 황교수의 “말하는 방식에 문제는 있지만, 사실 올바른 지적” 이라며 황교수의 입장을 변호하는 사람들도 있었다.

김연아의 소속사인 올댓스포츠는 일전에 황교수가 진정성을 갖춰 사과 한다면 고소를 취하할 생각이 있다고 밝힌 적이 있다.


  • 1. Ghost camera captures underage sex
  • 2. Army deploys Surion copters
  • 3. NK special envoy in Beijing
  • 4. Man in love with military career
  • 5. Female body found in singer's car; suicide suspected
  • 6. Two men cleared of spy charges decades after guilty verdict
  • 7. Fancy a burn-up? £200,000 supercar goes up in flames
  • 8. Looser dress code due for public servants in summer
  • 9. Ex-girlfriend of singer found dead in his car
  • 10. Samsung to purchase 10% stake in Pantech


Copyeditors, cartoonist wanted
‘Expat citizen reporters’ wanted
Koreatimes.co.kr puts on a new dress